An Aviation Lesson for Surgeons: Why Structured Debriefing Is One Key to Mastery in Orthopaedic Surgery

In high-stakes environments, from surgical suites to the skies, there exists a shared understanding: The job is not finished until the debrief is done. For orthopaedic surgeons, every surgery carries the weight of life-altering consequences. Yet, unlike professions where post-performance review is standard—such as aviation or military operations—surgical debriefing is often informal or inconsistent. This gap can hinder personal growth, team learning, and patient outcomes. This article will examine the power of structured debriefing in orthopaedic surgery, drawing parallels to other high-stakes professions, and will argue that the debrief should become an ingrained part of the surgical process.

A culture of debrief: lessons from aviation and military precision
Aviation, particularly in high-stakes organizations such as the Blue Angels or commercial airlines, operates under an assumption that mistakes or lapses in judgment could have catastrophic outcomes. The Blue Angels, the U.S. Navy’s flight demonstration squadron, are renowned for their meticulous approach to debriefing. After every performance, pilots engage in a rigorous, unfiltered review of their maneuvers, openly identifying and discussing every minute error—whether it was visible to the audience or not. This thorough debriefing culture fosters an environment where accountability and improvement are prioritized above ego. Errors are seen not as failings of the individual but as opportunities for the entire team to learn.

The aviation industry has long understood that structured debriefing is essential for safety. After every flight, pilots and flight crews participate in debriefs where they openly discuss any issues that occurred during the flight. This practice has been linked to significant reductions in errors and has led to improved safety standards that are upheld across the industry. Translating these insights to surgical settings, where patients’ lives are directly impacted by minute decisions, seems not only logical but necessary.

In orthopaedic surgery, every procedure is a high-stakes endeavor. Lives may not be on the line in the same immediate sense as in aviation, but quality of life and long-term functionality for patients absolutely are. Despite this, the postoperative debrief often remains underutilized. Traditional debriefs, if conducted, might focus solely on objective outcomes rather than providing a holistic reflection of the procedure. A formalized, non-punitive debriefing process can transform surgical practice by fostering a mindset of continuous improvement and team cohesion.

In surgery, as in flight, tiny details matter. An oversight in the angle of an implant or a delay in identifying a complication can have ripple effects for the patient’s recovery and quality of life. Just as pilots meticulously review each flight to ensure safe landings and future improvement, surgeons need to adopt the same reflective lens. Structured debriefs encourage the surgical team to re-examine each part of a procedure with objectivity and honesty, allowing them to identify areas where things went well and others where they might improve. This practice can bridge knowledge gaps and promote a culture that embraces learning over blame.

Beyond the technical: addressing team dynamics and communication
Structured debriefs allow for more than just technical reflection. They create a forum where team dynamics and communication issues can also be addressed. In orthopaedic surgery, where teamwork is paramount, debriefing can reveal potential disconnects in communication that may not be obvious in the moment but can impact patient care. Communication lapses, lack of clarity in roles, and insufficient situational awareness are common barriers in the OR. These issues, if left unaddressed, can create tension and increase the likelihood of errors.

Drawing parallels from the Blue Angels, their debriefs focus not only on maneuvers but also on team cohesion and communication. Each team member can speak openly, addressing any concerns without fear of judgment. Similarly, orthopaedic surgery teams can use debriefs to foster an environment of trust and respect. When team members feel that their voices matter, they are more likely to bring up potential concerns, whether about the procedure or interpersonal interactions. This trust promotes a collaborative culture where every team member feels empowered to contribute to a safer and more efficient surgical process.

A roadmap for implementing effective debriefs in orthopaedic surgery
Although the importance of debriefing is evident, implementing it effectively requires intentional planning. A structured surgical debrief should include several key components:

1. Preparation: Designate a specific time for debriefing after each surgery, making it clear that this is as critical as the surgery itself. Avoid rushing or omitting this process due to time constraints. Just as a pilot would not skip a post-flight review, a surgeon should prioritize postsurgical debriefing.
2. Creating a non-punitive environment: Debriefs should be conducted in an environment free from blame. Establish clear ground rules that emphasize learning and improvement over criticism. The focus should be on identifying root causes and implementing solutions, rather than assigning fault.
3. Structured reflection: The debrief should cover both technical and interpersonal elements. Start with objective elements such as surgical outcomes, timing, and steps, and then move to more subjective areas such as communication, teamwork, and situational awareness. Each team member should be given the opportunity to speak and contribute their insights.
4. Documentation and feedback: Documenting the debriefing session allows the team to track recurring issues and monitor improvements over time. Establishing a feedback loop ensures that the insights gathered during debriefs lead to tangible changes in practice.
5. Continuous improvement: Recognize that effective debriefing is an evolving process. Encourage feedback on the debriefing process, and be open to adjustments that make it more effective and engaging for the entire team.

When debriefing becomes a standard practice, it builds a culture that values reflection, accountability, and continuous improvement. Teams that regularly debrief are not only more prepared to handle unexpected challenges but also more resilient in the face of setbacks. In orthopaedic surgery, this could mean better patient outcomes, fewer complications, and a more cohesive and engaged surgical team.

For trainees and residents, debriefing offers invaluable educational opportunities. It is a chance to see experienced surgeons model humility, openness to feedback, and a dedication to learning. These are qualities that young surgeons can carry with them throughout their careers, building a new generation of orthopaedic professionals who prioritize safety, empathy, and precision.

Orthopaedic surgery is as much an art as it is a science, and like any high-stakes art, it demands reflection and refinement. Debriefing is not merely a tool for learning from errors but an essential practice for fostering mastery and excellence. By embracing debriefing as a core part of the surgical process, orthopaedic surgeons can draw lessons from fields such as aviation and the military, where structured reflection is ingrained into every aspect of training and operations. Through regular, structured, and non-punitive debriefing, orthopaedic teams can elevate their practice; improve patient outcomes; and build a culture of trust, transparency, and lifelong learning. Just as a pilot’s job is not finished until the plane is safely on the ground, a surgeon’s work is not complete until the team has collectively reflected on the experience and committed to future improvement.

Sean A. Tabaie, MD, MBA, FAAOS, is a pediatric orthopaedic surgeon and associate professor at Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, where he leads the Neuro-Orthopaedics Program and serves as medical director of the Honda Center for Gait Analysis and Mobility Enhancement. Dr. Tabaie is also a member of the AAOS Board of Directors.

Lessons from the ultimate aviation instructor: Ambassador Sullenberger